However, a report from ProPublica and Columbia Journalism found online dating companies aren’t necessarily equipped to handle user complaints related to sexual assault allegations appropriately.
“They’ve just been garbage at actually having meaningful responses to victims who’ve reported violence on their apps,” said Carrie Goldberg, a Brooklyn attorney specializing in sexual privacy violations.
Goldberg consulted on the ProPublica report, which revealed dating platforms often hire low-paid “content moderators” to respond to sexual assault complaints. These employees have no special training and must meet hourly quotas.
“A content moderator is supposed to, you know, within an average of one to four minutes, deal with a user who is saying that I just got sexually assaulted by somebody that uses your platform that you basically presented to me,” Goldberg explained.
Also uncovered in the report was a pattern of unanswered complaints or boilerplate responses, which Goldberg said can traumatize victims a second time.
“If you have millions of users…there are going to be complaints about sexual assault,” Goldberg said. “And it’s shocking if a platform doesn’t have a really good way of addressing it from Day One.”
Most online dating platforms are owned by Match Group — including Match, OkCupid, Tinder, Hinge, Plenty of Fish and Our Time — representing about 90% of the online dating market. Bumble is the second-most popular dating app and is not owned by Match Group.
“Bumble, by far, is leagues ahead of the other apps,” Goldberg said. “We’ve just found them to be so much more responsive.”
Regardless of the platform, where there’s a will, there’s a way.
“We’ve seen, even within Match Group, where if somebody gets banned on one Match product, like OkCupid, they might come create a profile on Tinder,” Goldberg explained.
But it’s rare for any company to be held legally responsible for a user’s offline actions. Goldberg blames that partly on an often-cited portion of the 1996 Federal Communication Decency Act – Section 230 – which shields website hosts from claims related to user-posted content.
“It’s really extraordinary that an entire industry is not liable for their product,” said Goldberg. “Even the gun industry, if their product malfunctions, if a gun blows up in your face, you can still sue the gun company.”
NewsNation affiliate WPIX reached out to Bumble and Match Group for comment.
Match Group declined to give an interview or answer any questions. Instead, the company directed WPIX to its safety policies, including an online network of tools to detect fraud, verify user identity and flag inappropriate behavior. Match Group said each brand has a robust customer care team that reports serious violations to a centralized safety repository.
Bumble did answer WPIX’s questions. The company said its default policy is to believe the victim or survivor, and immediately ban the accused from the platform while investigating. Bumble said any harassment or assault complaint is routed to its dedicated safety support team, which can also provide information about counseling services and law enforcement.
Goldberg, however, isn’t quite sold. “Don’t trust the app,” she said. “Don’t trust that they’re doing anything to prevent predators and abusers from being there.”